Prop Firm Basics: How Do Prop Firms Work?
Prop firms are the latest trend to hit the retail trading space, but what are they and how do they work?
If you’ve spent more than a few minutes scrolling on social media, you’ve probably seen someone waving a payout certificate, claiming they’ve just bagged $20,000 thanks to a “prop firm”.
For those new to the game it all sounds like easy money. But as with most things in trading, the reality is a little more complicated, and a lot less glamorous.
What is a Prop Firm?
A proprietary trading firm, commonly shortened to “prop firm”, is a company that allows traders to trade the firm’s capital, rather than their own. In return, the trader keeps a percentage of any profits they make, while the firm covers the losses. Sounds fair, right? But there’s a catch, or several, depending on how you look at it.
To access this capital, traders first need to pass a challenge. This is essentially a simulated trading test with strict rules and targets. Usually, the challenge involves hitting a profit target, such as 10%, without breaching a maximum drawdown or daily loss limit.
The rules are tight and often unforgiving. One slip, one misjudged trade, and it’s back to the beginning. Only a small fraction of traders pass these evaluations, and an even smaller number actually receive multiple payouts. Most blow up their accounts in the first few days, often within hours.
A Win for the House
Here’s the part that rarely gets talked about, and this is by design.
Prop firms make a significant chunk of their revenue not from successful traders, but from those who fail the challenge. The challenge fee, which ranges from about $100 to over $1000 depending on the account size you want to be “funded” with, is paid up front. Whether you pass or not, the firm keeps that fee. Multiply that by tens of thousands of hopeful traders each month and you start to understand the real business model.
A common misconception is that prop firms only benefit when their traders are profitable. In reality, most firms thrive because so many fail. It’s a numbers game. They profit from challenge fees, reattempts, and resets. There’s little incentive for them to create a test that’s easy to pass. If too many traders pass, the model breaks down. It’s essentially a pay-to-play environment where the odds are stacked in favour of the house.
The Prop Firm Pass Rate
The pass rate for prop firm challenges is estimated to be around 10%. That means nine out of ten traders fail. Let that sink in. This isn’t some niche statistic buried in fine print, it’s the foundation of the entire business model.
The fact that the overwhelming majority of traders don’t make it past the first stage is exactly why the prop firm industry has seen a huge boom. It’s incredibly profitable. Traders are constantly paying for challenges they’re unlikely to pass, and when they fail, many go straight back in, thinking the next run will be different.
For the firms, it’s a steady stream of income with minimal risk. They don’t have to pay out most of the time, because most people never make it that far. The odds are slim by design, and that’s what keeps the engine running.
No Account Rolling!
Prop firms can tolerate many things, but account rolling isn’t one of them. Account rolling is when a trader takes outsized risks in an attempt to rack up big profits, often driven more by luck than skill. If the account blows up, no problem, they simply buy a new challenge and try again.
The logic is simple, they risk a small upfront fee for the chance to walk away with a much larger payout. But for the prop firm, this kind of behaviour is a headache. While the firm earns from repeated challenge fees, they also face the risk of paying out to traders who stumble into profit through sheer volatility rather than any real edge. It’s not a sustainable model for them, which is why many firms are tightening their rules or quietly implementing limits to prevent this kind of repetition.
The goal for most prop firms isn’t to reward aggressive risk taking, it’s to find stable, consistent traders who can generate long-term returns within a controlled risk framework.
It’s not all Bad
Despite the risks and the low success rate, prop firms can offer genuine benefits, especially for those who don’t have access to large amounts of trading capital. If you’re highly disciplined, have a consistent strategy and can manage risk under pressure, the model can work in your favour. But don’t let the marketing fool you. It’s not free money. It’s a test, and a tough one at that.
Regulation – The grey area
Most prop firms are not regulated financial institutions. They’re not brokers, and they don’t handle client funds in the traditional sense. This gives them a degree of freedom, but also means traders have limited protection if things go wrong. That said, some of the more established firms voluntarily follow regulatory frameworks or adhere to operational standards that mirror those seen in the regulated space. These tend to be the ones with transparent rules, clear payout structures and responsive support. But again, they’re the minority.
Berto
Believe the Hype?
One point that often gets overlooked, is that many of the influencers promoting prop firms are affiliate marketers. They earn a commission every time someone signs up using their link. This creates a strong financial incentive to oversell the dream, while downplaying the harsh realities. They’ll show you the payouts, but not the blown accounts. The success stories, not the graveyard of failed attempts. It’s important to approach these posts with a sceptical eye.
The prop firm model is a clever monetisation of the retail trading boom. It taps into the desire to be a trader without risking personal funds. But make no mistake, it’s still your money on the line, just paid up front in a different form.
If you’re going to give it a go, do it with your eyes wide open. Study the rules. Read the fine print. And don’t be fooled by the flashy marketing. Prop trading isn’t a shortcut to riches. It’s a high-pressure, high-stakes game, and only a few truly win.
Berto